Predictions
Alejandro Garnacho has faced no shortage of criticism since arriving at Chelsea, but the Argentine winger delivered when it mattered most in the Carabao Cup semi-final against Arsenal.
Chelsea signed Garnacho from Manchester United for £40 million, a move that raised eyebrows following a turbulent spell at Old Trafford. His time with the Red Devils ended amid reports of him being placed in their version of a “bomb squad”, followed by a fallout with Ruben Amorim over his future.
Early signs at Chelsea were mixed. Garnacho was criticised for his attitude during the FA Cup win over Charlton, where he failed to track back and support his teammates defensively. But against Arsenal, the 20-year-old responded in the best possible way.
Also Read
A Big-Game Response at the Perfect Time
This was a very different Garnacho.
Introduced from the bench, he produced a clinical brace that kept Chelsea alive in the tie and showcased exactly what he brings when fully engaged. Direct running, composure in front of goal, and relentless intent — everything fans have been desperate to see.
Consistency remains the biggest question mark hanging over Garnacho’s game. On his day, he can be unplayable. On others, he can drift out of matches. But nights like this are why Chelsea invested so heavily in his potential.
Alejandro Garnacho Writes Himself Into Chelsea History
Remarkably, Garnacho didn’t just score twice — he made history.
He is now the first substitute in Chelsea’s 121-year history to score two goals in a major domestic cup semi-final (FA Cup or League Cup).
Even iconic “super subs” like Gianfranco Zola never achieved that feat.
To make it even sweeter, Garnacho had never scored a competitive goal against Arsenal during his three seasons at Manchester United. Doing it twice — in a semi-final, in Chelsea blue — makes this performance all the more special.
A Performance That Demands a Reward
Pedro Neto has come under scrutiny in recent weeks for inconsistent displays, and his performance against Arsenal reflected that mixed form. While he showed flashes of quality — including the cross that led to Garnacho’s first goal — there were periods where his influence faded.
Interestingly, Garnacho shares a similar profile. Explosive, unpredictable, and capable of match-winning moments — but prone to disappearing acts.
That said, Liam Rosenior now has a clear opportunity to send a message to the squad.
After a 9/10 performance, Garnacho has earned serious consideration for a starting role against Brentford. Rewarding impact, intensity, and end product is exactly how standards are set — and how confidence is built.
Final Thoughts
Garnacho’s Chelsea career is still very much a work in progress, but this was a reminder of his ceiling. If he can channel this level of focus and commitment consistently, Chelsea may yet have uncovered a decisive weapon for the second half of the season.
Fixtures and Results
Transfers
Injuries
Chelsea Academy
Chelsea Women